The Sundance Film Festival has always felt like a fresh start to kick off a new year of cinema. With no preconceived expectations, the festival serves as an annual cinematic discovery, unearthing gems that will ultimately shape the year’s film landscape. From directorial debuts to high-profile premieres, Sundance never fails to deliver a diverse and compelling selection of films.

This year, debut and second features have stood out the most, and one of those films is James Sweeney’s follow-up to Straight Up, Twinless. A film that navigates the complex nature of grief, self-discovery, and the deep desire for companionship, Twinless blends emotional depth with moments of sharp, dark humor.

The story follows Roman and Denis, two individuals attending a support group for those who have lost their twin. After crossing paths at a meeting, they form a friendship at a moment in their lives when they need it most. As their bond grows, the two navigate their grief in distinct and deeply personal ways, all while forging a connection that proves to be transformative.

James Sweeney’s screenplay effectively balances poignant, emotional moments with well-placed humor, even in its more subdued scenes—I’m looking at you, It Takes Two cameo. While not every comedic beat fully lands, the film’s exploration of human connection during one’s darkest moments remains its most resonant and impactful element.

Elevating the film’s script are the performances of both Sweeney and Dylan O’Brien. Offering nuanced portrayals of isolation and codependency, the duo bring a raw vulnerability to their roles, crafting a bromance that’s impossible to look away from. Their on-screen chemistry is electric—so much so that it’s hard not to hope for future collaborations.

The ever-reliable Lauren Graham delivers one of the film’s most heartbreaking moments. As a mother coping with the loss of her son while simultaneously offering support to others, Graham proves once again why she remains one of the most dependable character actors working today.

In true Brian De Palma fashion, Sweeney introduces a plot development that will likely be the make-or-break moment for audiences. While jarring, those willing to go along for the ride will find that the film ultimately sticks the landing.

Twinless cements James Sweeney as a rising voice in independent cinema, offering a fresh perspective on grief, human connection, and the process of moving forward. While certain narrative choices keep it from reaching the heights of greatness, it remains a strong entry and a noteworthy addition to the year’s first major film festival.