David's Reel ReviewsNYFFReel ReviewsReel Talk Inc

NYFF63: State of the Main Slate & Spotlight Section

Nouvelle Vague

Through my time as a lover of cinema, one of the voices that has consistently stood out to me has been Richard Linklater. His use of conversation as cinematic action is always appreciated, as he turns what might seem like mundane spaces into places where huge interpersonal retrospectives unfold. In turn, Linklater elevates the casual.

With his latest film, Nouvelle Vague, Richard Linklater takes the concept of “the making of” and, in paying tribute to one of the most important films of all time, Breathless, creates a Linklater special: a quintessential hangout movie that never feels inaccessible.

Nouvelle Vague works best when its screenplay leans into its effortless rhythm of blending casual dialogue with film history. Peeling back the legacy of Breathless in this fashion removes the sense of an academic venture and instead immerses you in Godard, Seberg, Belmondo, and the mythos surrounding that landmark film. Speaking of that trio, Guillaume Marbeck, Zoey Deutch, and Aubry Dullin are wonderful throughout. Marbeck evokes Godard and gives the film its grounded center. Deutch is easily best in show as she brings a playful spark and charm, and her chemistry with Dullin syncs perfectly with Linklater’s style, making these individuals feel like people we know.

Despite the vibes of a Linklater hangout film, this is not revolutionary or ground breaking, so if you are expecting major reinvention you might walk away disappointed. Even so, Richard Linklater’s Nouvelle Vague is a vivid reminder of why his voice remains prominent, a director still able to take a subject matter and never lose his infectious style..

Anemone

Daniel Day-Lewis is considered one of the finest actors of all time, and since stepping away in 2017, cinephiles have been clamoring for a potential return of the king. That return has finally arrived in the form of a collaboration with his son Ronan Day-Lewis and his feature debut film Anemone. The question leading into its New York Film Festival premiere was a simple one: would it be worth the wait?

After The Hunt

Luca Guadagnino has been on quite a run since 2017’s Call Me By Your Name. Luca has rolled out a résumé that includes Suspiria, Bones and All, Queer, and my favorite of the bunch, Challengers. With such an impressive streak, his latest film, After the Hunt, felt like another home run, especially with an ensemble that includes Julia Roberts, Andrew Garfield, and Ayo Edebiri. The reality is that After the Hunt is not just one of the most frustrating films of the year, but may be in line with Luca’s weakest film in his filmography.

Nora Garrett’s screenplay arrives with a premise that sounds like it should cut deep. However, it never finds the emotional edge and depth it keeps signaling toward. While the idea of fractured identity and character is an interesting one on the surface, Garrett’s script is flat and frustratingly unsure of how to guide you toward that meaning, which leads to a weightless experience.

Julia Roberts and Andrew Garfield do the best they can with the material they are given, while Ayo Edebiri feels a bit miscast in her role. Despite that, the three are fully committed, with Michael Stuhlbarg giving my favorite performance of the film. His turn made me long for a standalone short of Stuhlbarg’s Frederik Mendelssohn wandering the kitchen lost in his own rituals.

After the Hunt’s lasting impression is not one of provocation or boldness, but one of disappointment. For a film that aims to spark a burning conversation, it barely even ignites a flicker. It wants to confront subject matter that is raw and uncomfortable, but it only scratches the surface, and quickly fades away after the credits roll.

David Gonzalez
David Gonzalez is the founder and chief film critic of The Cinematic Reel (formerly Reel Talk Inc.) and host of the Reel Chronicles podcasts. A Cuban American independent film critic, David has built The Cinematic Reel around passionate, thoughtful film criticism spanning every genre, while championing diverse voices and perspectives across the industry. David is a Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer-Approved Critic and currently serves as Vice President of the New Jersey Film Critics Circle (NJFCC). He is also a member of New York Film Critics Online (NYFCO), the Online Film Critics Society (OFCS), and the Latino Entertainment Journalists Association (LEJA). His festival coverage has included the Sundance Film Festival, Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF), New York Film Festival (NYFF), Tribeca Festival, and SXSW, among others. Through The Cinematic Reel, David provides year-round reviews, festival coverage, awards-season analysis, interviews, and commentary on both major studio releases and independent cinema. An avid film collector, lifelong cinephile, and dedicated awards watcher, David brings an enthusiastic and knowledgeable perspective to his writing and podcasting. His criticism has been featured in film marketing campaigns and physical-media releases, further establishing The Cinematic Reel as a growing independent voice in film criticism. For screening invitations, review opportunities, festival coverage, and other press inquiries, David can be reached at david@thecinematicreel.com.

    Comments are closed.